com.google.javascript.jscomp.CheckAccessControls Maven / Gradle / Ivy
Show all versions of closure-compiler-linter Show documentation
/*
* Copyright 2008 The Closure Compiler Authors.
*
* Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
* you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
* You may obtain a copy of the License at
*
* http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
*
* Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
* distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
* WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
* See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
* limitations under the License.
*/
package com.google.javascript.jscomp;
import static com.google.common.base.Preconditions.checkArgument;
import static com.google.common.base.Preconditions.checkState;
import com.google.auto.value.AutoValue;
import com.google.common.collect.HashMultimap;
import com.google.common.collect.ImmutableMap;
import com.google.common.collect.Multimap;
import com.google.javascript.jscomp.NodeTraversal.Callback;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.JSDocInfo;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.JSDocInfo.Visibility;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.Node;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.StaticSourceFile;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.jstype.FunctionType;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.jstype.JSType;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.jstype.JSTypeNative;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.jstype.JSTypeRegistry;
import com.google.javascript.rhino.jstype.ObjectType;
import java.util.Deque;
import java.util.LinkedList;
import java.util.Objects;
import java.util.function.Supplier;
import javax.annotation.Nullable;
/**
* A compiler pass that checks that the programmer has obeyed all the access control restrictions
* indicated by JSDoc annotations, like {@code @private} and {@code @deprecated}.
*
* Because access control restrictions are attached to type information, this pass must run after
* TypeInference, and InferJSDocInfo.
*
* @author [email protected] (Nick Santos)
*/
class CheckAccessControls implements Callback, HotSwapCompilerPass {
static final DiagnosticType DEPRECATED_NAME = DiagnosticType.disabled(
"JSC_DEPRECATED_VAR",
"Variable {0} has been deprecated.");
static final DiagnosticType DEPRECATED_NAME_REASON = DiagnosticType.disabled(
"JSC_DEPRECATED_VAR_REASON",
"Variable {0} has been deprecated: {1}");
static final DiagnosticType DEPRECATED_PROP = DiagnosticType.disabled(
"JSC_DEPRECATED_PROP",
"Property {0} of type {1} has been deprecated.");
static final DiagnosticType DEPRECATED_PROP_REASON = DiagnosticType.disabled(
"JSC_DEPRECATED_PROP_REASON",
"Property {0} of type {1} has been deprecated: {2}");
static final DiagnosticType DEPRECATED_CLASS = DiagnosticType.disabled(
"JSC_DEPRECATED_CLASS",
"Class {0} has been deprecated.");
static final DiagnosticType DEPRECATED_CLASS_REASON = DiagnosticType.disabled(
"JSC_DEPRECATED_CLASS_REASON",
"Class {0} has been deprecated: {1}");
static final DiagnosticType BAD_PACKAGE_PROPERTY_ACCESS =
DiagnosticType.error(
"JSC_BAD_PACKAGE_PROPERTY_ACCESS",
"Access to package-private property {0} of {1} not allowed here.");
static final DiagnosticType BAD_PRIVATE_GLOBAL_ACCESS =
DiagnosticType.error(
"JSC_BAD_PRIVATE_GLOBAL_ACCESS",
"Access to private variable {0} not allowed outside file {1}.");
static final DiagnosticType BAD_PRIVATE_PROPERTY_ACCESS =
DiagnosticType.warning(
"JSC_BAD_PRIVATE_PROPERTY_ACCESS",
"Access to private property {0} of {1} not allowed here.");
static final DiagnosticType BAD_PROTECTED_PROPERTY_ACCESS =
DiagnosticType.warning(
"JSC_BAD_PROTECTED_PROPERTY_ACCESS",
"Access to protected property {0} of {1} not allowed here.");
static final DiagnosticType
BAD_PROPERTY_OVERRIDE_IN_FILE_WITH_FILEOVERVIEW_VISIBILITY =
DiagnosticType.error(
"JSC_BAD_PROPERTY_OVERRIDE_IN_FILE_WITH_FILEOVERVIEW_VISIBILITY",
"Overridden property {0} in file with fileoverview visibility {1}"
+ " must explicitly redeclare superclass visibility");
static final DiagnosticType PRIVATE_OVERRIDE =
DiagnosticType.warning(
"JSC_PRIVATE_OVERRIDE",
"Overriding private property of {0}.");
static final DiagnosticType EXTEND_FINAL_CLASS =
DiagnosticType.error(
"JSC_EXTEND_FINAL_CLASS",
"{0} is not allowed to extend final class {1}.");
static final DiagnosticType VISIBILITY_MISMATCH =
DiagnosticType.warning(
"JSC_VISIBILITY_MISMATCH",
"Overriding {0} property of {1} with {2} property.");
static final DiagnosticType CONST_PROPERTY_REASSIGNED_VALUE =
DiagnosticType.warning(
"JSC_CONSTANT_PROPERTY_REASSIGNED_VALUE",
"constant property {0} assigned a value more than once");
static final DiagnosticType CONST_PROPERTY_DELETED =
DiagnosticType.warning(
"JSC_CONSTANT_PROPERTY_DELETED",
"constant property {0} cannot be deleted");
static final DiagnosticType CONVENTION_MISMATCH =
DiagnosticType.warning(
"JSC_CONVENTION_MISMATCH",
"Declared access conflicts with access convention.");
private final AbstractCompiler compiler;
private final JSTypeRegistry typeRegistry;
private final boolean enforceCodingConventions;
// State about the current traversal.
private int deprecationDepth = 0;
// NOTE: LinkedList is almost always the wrong choice, but in this case we have at most a small
// handful of elements, it provides the smoothest API (push, pop, and a peek that doesn't throw
// on empty), and (unlike ArrayDeque) is null-permissive. No other option meets all these needs.
private final Deque currentClassStack = new LinkedList<>();
private ImmutableMap defaultVisibilityForFiles;
private final Multimap initializedConstantProperties;
CheckAccessControls(
AbstractCompiler compiler, boolean enforceCodingConventions) {
this.compiler = compiler;
this.typeRegistry = compiler.getTypeRegistry();
this.initializedConstantProperties = HashMultimap.create();
this.enforceCodingConventions = enforceCodingConventions;
}
@Override
public void process(Node externs, Node root) {
CollectFileOverviewVisibility collectPass =
new CollectFileOverviewVisibility(compiler);
collectPass.process(externs, root);
defaultVisibilityForFiles = collectPass.getFileOverviewVisibilityMap();
NodeTraversal.traverse(compiler, externs, this);
NodeTraversal.traverse(compiler, root, this);
}
@Override
public void hotSwapScript(Node scriptRoot, Node originalRoot) {
CollectFileOverviewVisibility collectPass =
new CollectFileOverviewVisibility(compiler);
collectPass.hotSwapScript(scriptRoot, originalRoot);
defaultVisibilityForFiles = collectPass.getFileOverviewVisibilityMap();
NodeTraversal.traverse(compiler, scriptRoot, this);
}
private void enterAccessControlScope(Node root) {
@Nullable ObjectType scopeType = bestInstanceTypeForMethodOrCtor(root);
if (isMarkedDeprecated(root)) {
deprecationDepth++;
}
currentClassStack.push(scopeType);
}
private void exitAccessControlScope(Node root) {
if (isMarkedDeprecated(root)) {
deprecationDepth--;
}
currentClassStack.pop();
}
/**
* Maps {@code node} to the primary root of an access-control scope if it is some root,
* or {@code null} if it is a non-root of the scope.
*
* We define access-control scopes differently from {@code Scope}s because of mismatches
* between ECMAScript scoping and our AST structure (e.g. the `extends` clause of a CLASS). {@link
* NodeTraveral} is designed to walk the AST in ECMAScript scope order, which is not the pre-order
* traversal that we would prefer here. This requires us to treat access-control scopes as a
* forest with a primary root.
*
*
Each access-control scope corresponds to some "owner" JavaScript type which is used when
* computing access-controls. At this time, each also corresponds to an AST subtree.
*
*
Known mismatches:
*
*
* - CLASS extends clause: secondary root of the scope defined by the CLASS.
*
*/
@Nullable
private static Node primaryAccessControlScopeRootFor(Node node) {
if (isExtendsTarget(node)) {
return node.getParent();
} else if (isFunctionOrClass(node)) {
return node;
} else {
return null;
}
}
/**
* Returns the instance object type that best represents a method or constructor definition, or
* {@code null} if there is no representative type.
*
*
* - Prototype methods => The instance type having that prototype
*
- Instance methods => The type the method is attached to
*
- Constructors => The type that constructor instantiates
*
- Object-literal members => The object-literal type
*
*/
@Nullable
private ObjectType bestInstanceTypeForMethodOrCtor(Node n) {
checkState(isFunctionOrClass(n), n);
Node parent = n.getParent();
// We need to handle declaration syntaxes separately in a way that we can't determine based on
// the type of just one node.
// TODO(nickreid): Determine if these can be replaced with FUNCTION and CLASS cases below.
if (NodeUtil.isFunctionDeclaration(n) || NodeUtil.isClassDeclaration(n)) {
return instanceTypeFor(n.getJSType());
}
// All the remaining cases can be isolated based on `parent`.
switch (parent.getToken()) {
case NAME:
return instanceTypeFor(n.getJSType());
case ASSIGN:
{
Node lValue = parent.getFirstChild();
if (NodeUtil.isGet(lValue)) {
// We have an assignment of the form `a.b = ...`.
JSType lValueType = lValue.getJSType();
if (lValueType != null && (lValueType.isConstructor() || lValueType.isInterface())) {
// Case `a.B = ...`
return instanceTypeFor(lValueType);
} else if (NodeUtil.isPrototypeProperty(lValue)) {
// Case `a.B.prototype = ...`
return instanceTypeFor(NodeUtil.getPrototypeClassName(lValue).getJSType());
} else {
// Case `a.b = ...`
return instanceTypeFor(lValue.getFirstChild().getJSType());
}
} else {
// We have an assignment of the form "a = ...", so pull the type off the "a".
return instanceTypeFor(lValue.getJSType());
}
}
case STRING_KEY:
case GETTER_DEF:
case SETTER_DEF:
case MEMBER_FUNCTION_DEF:
case COMPUTED_PROP:
{
Node grandparent = parent.getParent();
Node greatGrandparent = grandparent.getParent();
if (grandparent.isObjectLit()) {
return grandparent.getJSType().isFunctionPrototypeType()
// Case: `grandparent` is an object-literal prototype.
// Example: `Foo.prototype = { a: function() {} };` where `parent` is "a".
? instanceTypeFor(grandparent.getJSType())
: null;
} else if (greatGrandparent.isClass()) {
// Case: `n` is a class member definition.
// Example: `class Foo { a() {} }` where `parent` is "a".
return instanceTypeFor(greatGrandparent.getJSType());
} else {
// This would indicate the AST is malformed.
throw new AssertionError(greatGrandparent);
}
}
default:
return null;
}
}
/**
* Returns the type that best represents the instance type for {@code type}.
*
*
* - Prototype type => The instance type having that prototype
*
- Instance type => The type
*
- Constructor type => The type that constructor instantiates
*
- Object-literal type => The type
*
*/
@Nullable
private static ObjectType instanceTypeFor(JSType type) {
if (type == null) {
return null;
} else if (type.isUnionType()) {
return null; // A union has no meaningful instance type.
} else if (type.isInstanceType() || type.isUnknownType()) {
return type.toMaybeObjectType();
} else if (type.isConstructor() || type.isInterface()) {
return type.toMaybeFunctionType().getInstanceType();
} else if (type.isFunctionType()) {
return null; // Functions that aren't ctors or interfaces have no instance type.
} else if (type.isFunctionPrototypeType()) {
return instanceTypeFor(type.toMaybeObjectType().getOwnerFunction());
}
return type.toMaybeObjectType();
}
@Override
public boolean shouldTraverse(NodeTraversal traversal, Node node, Node parent) {
@Nullable Node accessControlRoot = primaryAccessControlScopeRootFor(node);
if (accessControlRoot != null) {
enterAccessControlScope(accessControlRoot);
}
return true;
}
@Override
public void visit(NodeTraversal traversal, Node node, Node parent) {
IdentifierBehaviour identifierBehaviour = IdentifierBehaviour.select(node);
@Nullable PropertyReference propRef = createPropertyReference(node);
checkDeprecation(node, propRef, identifierBehaviour, traversal);
checkVisibility(node, propRef, identifierBehaviour, traversal.getScope());
checkConstantProperty(propRef, identifierBehaviour);
checkFinalClassOverrides(node);
@Nullable Node accessControlRoot = primaryAccessControlScopeRootFor(node);
if (accessControlRoot != null) {
exitAccessControlScope(accessControlRoot);
}
}
private void checkDeprecation(
Node node,
@Nullable PropertyReference propRef,
IdentifierBehaviour identifierBehaviour,
NodeTraversal traversal) {
switch (identifierBehaviour) {
case ES5_CLASS_INVOCATION:
case ES6_CLASS_INVOCATION:
case ES6_CLASS_NAMESPACE:
// At these usages, treat the deprecation applied to type-declaration as referring to the
// type, not the identifier (e.g. "the use of class `Foo` is deprecated").
checkTypeDeprecation(traversal, node);
break;
case NON_CONSTRUCTOR:
// For all identifiers that are not constructors, deprecation refers to the identifier (e.g.
// "the use of variable `x` is deprecated").
checkNameDeprecation(traversal, node);
break;
default:
break;
}
if (propRef != null && !identifierBehaviour.equals(IdentifierBehaviour.ES5_CLASS_NAMESPACE)) {
checkPropertyDeprecation(traversal, propRef);
}
}
private void checkVisibility(
Node node,
@Nullable PropertyReference propRef,
IdentifierBehaviour identifierBehaviour,
Scope scope) {
if (identifierBehaviour.equals(IdentifierBehaviour.ES6_CLASS_INVOCATION)) {
checkEs6ConstructorInvocationVisibility(node);
}
if (!identifierBehaviour.equals(IdentifierBehaviour.ES5_CLASS_NAMESPACE)) {
checkNameVisibility(scope, node);
}
if (node.getParent().isObjectLit()) {
// TODO(b/80580110): Eventually object literals should be covered by `PropertyReference`s.
// However, doing so initially would have caused too many errors in existing code and
// delayed support for class syntax.
switch (node.getToken()) {
case STRING_KEY:
case GETTER_DEF:
case SETTER_DEF:
case MEMBER_FUNCTION_DEF:
checkKeyVisibilityConvention(node, node.getParent());
break;
default:
break;
}
}
if (propRef != null && !identifierBehaviour.equals(IdentifierBehaviour.ES5_CLASS_NAMESPACE)) {
checkPropertyVisibility(propRef);
}
}
/**
* Reports deprecation issue with regard to a type usage.
*
* Precondition: {@code n} has a constructor {@link JSType}.
*/
private void checkTypeDeprecation(NodeTraversal t, Node n) {
if (!shouldEmitDeprecationWarning(t, n)) {
return;
}
ObjectType instanceType = n.getJSType().toMaybeFunctionType().getInstanceType();
String deprecationInfo = getTypeDeprecationInfo(instanceType);
if (deprecationInfo == null) {
return;
}
DiagnosticType message = deprecationInfo.isEmpty() ? DEPRECATED_CLASS : DEPRECATED_CLASS_REASON;
compiler.report(JSError.make(n, message, instanceType.toString(), deprecationInfo));
}
/** Checks the given NAME node to ensure that access restrictions are obeyed. */
private void checkNameDeprecation(NodeTraversal t, Node n) {
if (!n.isName()) {
return;
}
if (!shouldEmitDeprecationWarning(t, n)) {
return;
}
Var var = t.getScope().getVar(n.getString());
JSDocInfo docInfo = var == null ? null : var.getJSDocInfo();
if (docInfo != null && docInfo.isDeprecated()) {
if (docInfo.getDeprecationReason() != null) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(n, DEPRECATED_NAME_REASON, n.getString(), docInfo.getDeprecationReason()));
} else {
compiler.report(JSError.make(n, DEPRECATED_NAME, n.getString()));
}
}
}
/** Checks the given GETPROP node to ensure that access restrictions are obeyed. */
private void checkPropertyDeprecation(NodeTraversal t, PropertyReference propRef) {
if (!shouldEmitDeprecationWarning(t, propRef)) {
return;
}
// Don't bother checking constructors.
if (propRef.getSourceNode().getParent().isNew()) {
return;
}
ObjectType objectType = castToObject(dereference(propRef.getReceiverType()));
String propertyName = propRef.getName();
if (objectType != null) {
String deprecationInfo
= getPropertyDeprecationInfo(objectType, propertyName);
if (deprecationInfo != null) {
if (!deprecationInfo.isEmpty()) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
propRef.getSourceNode(),
DEPRECATED_PROP_REASON,
propertyName,
propRef.getReadableTypeNameOrDefault(),
deprecationInfo));
} else {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
propRef.getSourceNode(),
DEPRECATED_PROP,
propertyName,
propRef.getReadableTypeNameOrDefault()));
}
}
}
}
private boolean isPrivateByConvention(String name) {
return enforceCodingConventions
&& compiler.getCodingConvention().isPrivate(name);
}
/**
* Determines whether the given OBJECTLIT property visibility violates the coding convention.
*
* @param key The objectlit key node (STRING_KEY, GETTER_DEF, SETTER_DEF, MEMBER_FUNCTION_DEF).
*/
private void checkKeyVisibilityConvention(Node key, Node parent) {
JSDocInfo info = key.getJSDocInfo();
if (info == null) {
return;
}
if (!isPrivateByConvention(key.getString())) {
return;
}
Node assign = parent.getParent();
if (assign == null || !assign.isAssign()) {
return;
}
Node left = assign.getFirstChild();
if (!left.isGetProp()
|| !left.getLastChild().getString().equals("prototype")) {
return;
}
Visibility declaredVisibility = info.getVisibility();
// Visibility is declared to be something other than private.
if (declaredVisibility != Visibility.INHERITED
&& declaredVisibility != Visibility.PRIVATE) {
compiler.report(JSError.make(key, CONVENTION_MISMATCH));
}
}
/**
* Reports an error if the given name is not visible in the current context.
*
* @param scope The current scope.
* @param name The name node.
*/
private void checkNameVisibility(Scope scope, Node name) {
if (!name.isName()) {
return;
}
Var var = scope.getVar(name.getString());
if (var == null) {
return;
}
Visibility v = checkPrivateNameConvention(
AccessControlUtils.getEffectiveNameVisibility(
name, var, defaultVisibilityForFiles), name);
switch (v) {
case PACKAGE:
if (!isPackageAccessAllowed(var, name)) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
name,
BAD_PACKAGE_PROPERTY_ACCESS,
name.getString(),
var.getSourceFile().getName()));
}
break;
case PRIVATE:
if (!isPrivateAccessAllowed(var, name)) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
name,
BAD_PRIVATE_GLOBAL_ACCESS,
name.getString(),
var.getSourceFile().getName()));
}
break;
default:
// Nothing to do for PUBLIC and PROTECTED
// (which is irrelevant for names).
break;
}
}
/**
* Returns the effective visibility of the given name, reporting an error
* if there is a contradiction in the various sources of visibility
* (example: a variable with a trailing underscore that is declared
* {@code @public}).
*/
private Visibility checkPrivateNameConvention(Visibility v, Node name) {
if (isPrivateByConvention(name.getString())) {
if (v != Visibility.PRIVATE && v != Visibility.INHERITED) {
compiler.report(JSError.make(name, CONVENTION_MISMATCH));
}
return Visibility.PRIVATE;
}
return v;
}
private static boolean isPrivateAccessAllowed(Var var, Node name) {
StaticSourceFile varSrc = var.getSourceFile();
StaticSourceFile refSrc = name.getStaticSourceFile();
return varSrc == null || refSrc == null || Objects.equals(varSrc.getName(), refSrc.getName());
}
private boolean isPackageAccessAllowed(Var var, Node name) {
StaticSourceFile varSrc = var.getSourceFile();
StaticSourceFile refSrc = name.getStaticSourceFile();
if (varSrc == null && refSrc == null) {
// If the source file of either var or name is unavailable, conservatively assume they belong
// to different packages.
//
// TODO(brndn): by contrast, isPrivateAccessAllowed does allow private access when a source
// file is unknown. I didn't change it in order not to break existing code.
return false;
}
CodingConvention codingConvention = compiler.getCodingConvention();
String srcPackage = codingConvention.getPackageName(varSrc);
String refPackage = codingConvention.getPackageName(refSrc);
return srcPackage != null && refPackage != null && Objects.equals(srcPackage, refPackage);
}
private void checkPropertyOverrideVisibilityIsSame(
Visibility overriding,
Visibility overridden,
@Nullable Visibility fileOverview,
PropertyReference propRef) {
if (overriding == Visibility.INHERITED
&& overriding != overridden
&& fileOverview != null
&& fileOverview != Visibility.INHERITED) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
propRef.getSourceNode(),
BAD_PROPERTY_OVERRIDE_IN_FILE_WITH_FILEOVERVIEW_VISIBILITY,
propRef.getName(),
fileOverview.name()));
}
}
@Nullable
private static Visibility getOverridingPropertyVisibility(PropertyReference propRef) {
JSDocInfo overridingInfo = propRef.getJSDocInfo();
return overridingInfo == null || !overridingInfo.isOverride()
? null
: overridingInfo.getVisibility();
}
/** Checks if a constructor is trying to override a final class. */
private void checkFinalClassOverrides(Node ctor) {
if (!isFunctionOrClass(ctor)) {
return;
}
JSType type = ctor.getJSType().toMaybeFunctionType();
if (type != null && type.isConstructor()) {
JSType finalParentClass = getSuperClassInstanceIfFinal(bestInstanceTypeForMethodOrCtor(ctor));
if (finalParentClass != null) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
ctor,
EXTEND_FINAL_CLASS,
type.getDisplayName(),
finalParentClass.getDisplayName()));
}
}
}
/** Determines whether the given constant property got reassigned */
private void checkConstantProperty(
@Nullable PropertyReference propRef, IdentifierBehaviour identifierBehaviour) {
if (propRef == null || identifierBehaviour.equals(IdentifierBehaviour.ES5_CLASS_NAMESPACE)) {
return;
}
if (!propRef.isMutation()) {
return;
}
ObjectType objectType = castToObject(dereference(propRef.getReceiverType()));
String propertyName = propRef.getName();
boolean isConstant = isPropertyDeclaredConstant(objectType, propertyName);
// Check whether constant properties are reassigned
if (isConstant) {
if (propRef.isDeletion()) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(propRef.getSourceNode(), CONST_PROPERTY_DELETED, propertyName));
return;
}
// Can't check for constant properties on generic function types.
// TODO(johnlenz): I'm not 100% certain this is necessary, or if
// the type is being inspected incorrectly.
if (objectType == null
|| (objectType.isFunctionType()
&& !objectType.toMaybeFunctionType().isConstructor())) {
return;
}
ObjectType oType = objectType;
while (oType != null) {
if (initializedConstantProperties.containsEntry(oType, propertyName)
|| initializedConstantProperties.containsEntry(
getCanonicalInstance(oType), propertyName)) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(propRef.getSourceNode(), CONST_PROPERTY_REASSIGNED_VALUE, propertyName));
break;
}
oType = oType.getImplicitPrototype();
}
initializedConstantProperties.put(objectType, propertyName);
// Add the prototype when we're looking at an instance object
if (objectType.isInstanceType()) {
ObjectType prototype = objectType.getImplicitPrototype();
if (prototype != null && prototype.hasProperty(propertyName)) {
initializedConstantProperties.put(prototype, propertyName);
}
}
}
}
/**
* Return an object with the same nominal type as obj,
* but without any possible extra properties that exist on obj.
*/
static ObjectType getCanonicalInstance(ObjectType obj) {
FunctionType ctor = obj.getConstructor();
return ctor == null ? obj : ctor.getInstanceType();
}
/** Dereference a type, autoboxing it and filtering out null. */
@Nullable
private static ObjectType dereference(JSType type) {
return type == null ? null : type.dereference();
}
private JSType typeOrUnknown(JSType type) {
return (type == null) ? typeRegistry.getNativeType(JSTypeNative.UNKNOWN_TYPE) : type;
}
private ObjectType typeOrUnknown(ObjectType type) {
return (ObjectType) typeOrUnknown((JSType) type);
}
private ObjectType boxedOrUnknown(@Nullable JSType type) {
return typeOrUnknown(dereference(type));
}
/**
* Reports an error if the given property is not visible in the current context.
*
*
This method covers both:
*
*
* - accesses to properties during execution
*
- overrides of properties during declaration
*
*
* TODO(nickreid): Things would probably be a lot simpler, though a bit duplicated, if these two
* concepts were separated. Much of the underlying logic could stop checking various inconsistent
* definitions of "is this an override".
*/
private void checkPropertyVisibility(PropertyReference propRef) {
if (NodeUtil.isEs6ConstructorMemberFunctionDef(propRef.getSourceNode())) {
// Class ctor *declarations* can never violate visibility restrictions. They are not
// accesses and we don't consider them overrides.
//
// TODO(nickreid): It would be a lot cleaner if we could model this using `PropertyReference`
// rather than defining a special case here. I think the problem is that the current
// implementation of this method conflates "override" with "declaration". But that only works
// because it ignores cases where there's no overridden definition.
return;
}
JSType rawReferenceType = typeOrUnknown(propRef.getReceiverType()).autobox();
ObjectType referenceType = castToObject(rawReferenceType);
String propertyName = propRef.getName();
boolean isPrivateByConvention = isPrivateByConvention(propertyName);
if (isPrivateByConvention && propertyIsDeclaredButNotPrivate(propRef)) {
compiler.report(JSError.make(propRef.getSourceNode(), CONVENTION_MISMATCH));
return;
}
StaticSourceFile definingSource =
AccessControlUtils.getDefiningSource(propRef.getSourceNode(), referenceType, propertyName);
// Is this a normal property access, or are we trying to override
// an existing property?
boolean isOverride = propRef.isDocumentedDeclaration() || propRef.isOverride();
ObjectType objectType = AccessControlUtils.getObjectType(
referenceType, isOverride, propertyName);
Visibility fileOverviewVisibility =
defaultVisibilityForFiles.get(definingSource);
Visibility visibility =
getEffectivePropertyVisibility(
propRef,
referenceType,
defaultVisibilityForFiles,
enforceCodingConventions ? compiler.getCodingConvention() : null);
if (isOverride) {
Visibility overriding = getOverridingPropertyVisibility(propRef);
if (overriding != null) {
checkPropertyOverrideVisibilityIsSame(
overriding, visibility, fileOverviewVisibility, propRef);
}
}
JSType reportType = rawReferenceType;
if (objectType != null) {
Node node = objectType.getOwnPropertyDefSite(propertyName);
if (node == null) {
// Assume the property is public.
return;
}
reportType = objectType;
definingSource = node.getStaticSourceFile();
} else if (!isPrivateByConvention && fileOverviewVisibility == null) {
// We can only check visibility references if we know what file
// it was defined in.
// Otherwise just assume the property is public.
return;
}
StaticSourceFile referenceSource = propRef.getSourceNode().getStaticSourceFile();
if (isOverride) {
boolean sameInput = referenceSource != null
&& referenceSource.getName().equals(definingSource.getName());
checkPropertyOverrideVisibility(
propRef, visibility, fileOverviewVisibility, reportType, sameInput);
} else {
checkPropertyAccessVisibility(
propRef, visibility, reportType, referenceSource, definingSource);
}
}
/**
* Reports visibility violations on ES6 class constructor invocations.
*
* Precondition: {@code target} has an ES6 class {@link JSType}.
*/
private void checkEs6ConstructorInvocationVisibility(Node target) {
FunctionType ctorType = target.getJSType().toMaybeFunctionType();
ObjectType prototypeType = ctorType.getPrototype();
// We use the class definition site because classes automatically get a implicit constructor,
// so there may not be a definition node.
@Nullable Node classDefinition = ctorType.getSource();
@Nullable
StaticSourceFile definingSource =
(classDefinition == null)
? null
: AccessControlUtils.getDefiningSource(classDefinition, prototypeType, "constructor");
// Synthesize a `PropertyReference` for this constructor call as if we're accessing
// `Foo.prototype.constructor`. This object allows us to reuse the
// `checkPropertyAccessVisibility` method which actually reports violations.
PropertyReference fauxCtorRef =
PropertyReference.builder()
.setSourceNode(target)
.setName("constructor")
.setReceiverType(prototypeType)
.setMutation(false) // This shouldn't matter.
.setDeclaration(false) // This shouldn't matter.
.setOverride(false) // This shouldn't matter.
.setReadableTypeName(() -> ctorType.getInstanceType().toString())
.build();
Visibility annotatedCtorVisibility =
// This function defaults to `INHERITED` which isn't what we want here, but it does handle
// combining inline and `@fileoverview` visibilities.
getEffectiveVisibilityForNonOverriddenProperty(
fauxCtorRef,
prototypeType,
defaultVisibilityForFiles.get(definingSource),
enforceCodingConventions ? compiler.getCodingConvention() : null);
Visibility effectiveCtorVisibility =
annotatedCtorVisibility.equals(Visibility.INHERITED)
? Visibility.PUBLIC
: annotatedCtorVisibility;
checkPropertyAccessVisibility(
fauxCtorRef,
effectiveCtorVisibility,
ctorType,
target.getStaticSourceFile(),
definingSource);
}
private static boolean propertyIsDeclaredButNotPrivate(PropertyReference propRef) {
if (!propRef.isDocumentedDeclaration() && !propRef.isOverride()) {
return false;
}
Visibility declaredVisibility = propRef.getJSDocInfo().getVisibility();
if (declaredVisibility == Visibility.PRIVATE || declaredVisibility == Visibility.INHERITED) {
return false;
}
return true;
}
private void checkPropertyOverrideVisibility(
PropertyReference propRef,
Visibility visibility,
Visibility fileOverviewVisibility,
JSType objectType,
boolean sameInput) {
Visibility overridingVisibility =
propRef.isOverride() ? propRef.getJSDocInfo().getVisibility() : Visibility.INHERITED;
// Check that:
// (a) the property *can* be overridden,
// (b) the visibility of the override is the same as the
// visibility of the original property,
// (c) the visibility is explicitly redeclared if the override is in
// a file with default visibility in the @fileoverview block.
if (visibility == Visibility.PRIVATE && !sameInput) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(propRef.getSourceNode(), PRIVATE_OVERRIDE, objectType.toString()));
} else if (overridingVisibility != Visibility.INHERITED
&& overridingVisibility != visibility
&& fileOverviewVisibility == null) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
propRef.getSourceNode(),
VISIBILITY_MISMATCH,
visibility.name(),
objectType.toString(),
overridingVisibility.name()));
}
}
private void checkPropertyAccessVisibility(
PropertyReference propRef,
Visibility visibility,
JSType objectType,
StaticSourceFile referenceSource,
StaticSourceFile definingSource) {
// private access is always allowed in the same file.
if (referenceSource != null
&& definingSource != null
&& referenceSource.getName().equals(definingSource.getName())) {
return;
}
@Nullable ObjectType ownerType = instanceTypeFor(objectType);
switch (visibility) {
case PACKAGE:
checkPackagePropertyVisibility(propRef, referenceSource, definingSource);
break;
case PRIVATE:
checkPrivatePropertyVisibility(propRef, ownerType);
break;
case PROTECTED:
checkProtectedPropertyVisibility(propRef, ownerType);
break;
default:
break;
}
}
private void checkPackagePropertyVisibility(
PropertyReference propRef,
StaticSourceFile referenceSource,
StaticSourceFile definingSource) {
CodingConvention codingConvention = compiler.getCodingConvention();
String refPackage = codingConvention.getPackageName(referenceSource);
String defPackage = codingConvention.getPackageName(definingSource);
if (refPackage == null
|| defPackage == null
|| !refPackage.equals(defPackage)) {
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
propRef.getSourceNode(),
BAD_PACKAGE_PROPERTY_ACCESS,
propRef.getName(),
propRef.getReadableTypeNameOrDefault()));
}
}
private void checkPrivatePropertyVisibility(
PropertyReference propRef,
@Nullable ObjectType ownerType) {
// private access is not allowed outside the file from a different
// enclosing class.
// TODO(tbreisacher): Should we also include the filename where ownerType is defined?
String readableTypeName =
ownerType == null || ownerType.equals(propRef.getReceiverType())
? propRef.getReadableTypeNameOrDefault()
: ownerType.toString();
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
propRef.getSourceNode(),
BAD_PRIVATE_PROPERTY_ACCESS,
propRef.getName(),
readableTypeName));
}
private void checkProtectedPropertyVisibility(
PropertyReference propRef, @Nullable ObjectType ownerType) {
// There are 3 types of legal accesses of a protected property:
// 1) Accesses in the same file
// 2) Overriding the property in a subclass
// 3) Accessing the property from inside a subclass
// The first two have already been checked for.
if (ownerType != null) {
for (JSType scopeType : currentClassStack) {
if (scopeType == null) {
continue;
} else if (scopeType.isSubtypeOf(ownerType)) {
return;
}
}
}
compiler.report(
JSError.make(
propRef.getSourceNode(),
BAD_PROTECTED_PROPERTY_ACCESS,
propRef.getName(),
propRef.getReadableTypeNameOrDefault()));
}
/**
* Determines whether a deprecation warning should be emitted.
*
* @param t The current traversal.
* @param n The node which we are checking.
* @param parent The parent of the node which we are checking.
*/
private boolean shouldEmitDeprecationWarning(NodeTraversal t, Node n) {
// In the global scope, there are only two kinds of accesses that should
// be flagged for warnings:
// 1) Calls of deprecated functions and methods.
// 2) Instantiations of deprecated classes.
// For now, we just let everything else by.
if (t.inGlobalScope()) {
if (!NodeUtil.isInvocationTarget(n) && !n.isNew()) {
return false;
}
}
return !canAccessDeprecatedTypes(t);
}
/** Determines whether a deprecation warning should be emitted. */
private boolean shouldEmitDeprecationWarning(NodeTraversal t, PropertyReference propRef) {
// In the global scope, there are only two kinds of accesses that should
// be flagged for warnings:
// 1) Calls of deprecated functions and methods.
// 2) Instantiations of deprecated classes.
// For now, we just let everything else by.
if (t.inGlobalScope()) {
if (!NodeUtil.isInvocationTarget(propRef.getSourceNode())) {
return false;
}
}
// We can always assign to a deprecated property, to keep it up to date.
if (propRef.isMutation()) {
return false;
}
// Don't warn if the node is just declaring the property, not reading it.
JSDocInfo jsdoc = propRef.getJSDocInfo();
if (propRef.isDeclaration() && (jsdoc != null) && jsdoc.isDeprecated()) {
return false;
}
return !canAccessDeprecatedTypes(t);
}
/**
* Returns whether it's currently OK to access deprecated names and
* properties.
*
* There are 3 exceptions when we're allowed to use a deprecated
* type or property:
* 1) When we're in a deprecated function.
* 2) When we're in a deprecated class.
* 3) When we're in a static method of a deprecated class.
*/
private boolean canAccessDeprecatedTypes(NodeTraversal t) {
Node scopeRoot = t.getClosestHoistScopeRoot();
if (NodeUtil.isFunctionBlock(scopeRoot)) {
scopeRoot = scopeRoot.getParent();
}
Node scopeRootParent = scopeRoot.getParent();
return
// Case #1
(deprecationDepth > 0)
// Case #2
|| (getTypeDeprecationInfo(getTypeOfThis(scopeRoot)) != null)
// Case #3
|| (scopeRootParent != null
&& scopeRootParent.isAssign()
&& getTypeDeprecationInfo(bestInstanceTypeForMethodOrCtor(scopeRoot)) != null);
}
/**
* Returns whether this node roots a subtree under which references to deprecated constructs are
* allowed.
*/
private static boolean isMarkedDeprecated(Node n) {
return getDeprecationReason(NodeUtil.getBestJSDocInfo(n)) != null;
}
/**
* Returns the deprecation reason for the type if it is marked
* as being deprecated. Returns empty string if the type is deprecated
* but no reason was given. Returns null if the type is not deprecated.
*/
private static String getTypeDeprecationInfo(JSType type) {
if (type == null) {
return null;
}
String depReason = getDeprecationReason(type.getJSDocInfo());
if (depReason != null) {
return depReason;
}
ObjectType objType = castToObject(type);
if (objType != null) {
ObjectType implicitProto = objType.getImplicitPrototype();
if (implicitProto != null) {
return getTypeDeprecationInfo(implicitProto);
}
}
return null;
}
private static String getDeprecationReason(JSDocInfo info) {
if (info != null && info.isDeprecated()) {
if (info.getDeprecationReason() != null) {
return info.getDeprecationReason();
}
return "";
}
return null;
}
/**
* Returns if a property is declared constant.
*/
private boolean isPropertyDeclaredConstant(
ObjectType objectType, String prop) {
if (enforceCodingConventions
&& compiler.getCodingConvention().isConstant(prop)) {
return true;
}
for (; objectType != null; objectType = objectType.getImplicitPrototype()) {
JSDocInfo docInfo = objectType.getOwnPropertyJSDocInfo(prop);
if (docInfo != null && docInfo.isConstant()) {
return true;
}
}
return false;
}
/**
* Returns the deprecation reason for the property if it is marked
* as being deprecated. Returns empty string if the property is deprecated
* but no reason was given. Returns null if the property is not deprecated.
*/
@Nullable
private static String getPropertyDeprecationInfo(ObjectType type, String prop) {
String depReason = getDeprecationReason(type.getOwnPropertyJSDocInfo(prop));
if (depReason != null) {
return depReason;
}
ObjectType implicitProto = type.getImplicitPrototype();
if (implicitProto != null) {
return getPropertyDeprecationInfo(implicitProto, prop);
}
return null;
}
/**
* If the superclass is final, this method returns an instance of the superclass.
*/
@Nullable
private static ObjectType getSuperClassInstanceIfFinal(@Nullable JSType type) {
if (type == null) {
return null;
}
ObjectType obj = type.toObjectType();
FunctionType ctor = (obj == null) ? null : obj.getSuperClassConstructor();
JSDocInfo doc = (ctor == null) ? null : ctor.getJSDocInfo();
if (doc != null && doc.isFinal()) {
return ctor.getInstanceType();
}
return null;
}
@Nullable
private static ObjectType castToObject(@Nullable JSType type) {
return type == null ? null : type.toMaybeObjectType();
}
private static boolean isFunctionOrClass(Node n) {
return n.isFunction() || n.isClass();
}
private static boolean isExtendsTarget(Node node) {
Node parent = node.getParent();
return parent.isClass() && node.isSecondChildOf(parent);
}
@Nullable
private JSType getTypeOfThis(Node scopeRoot) {
if (scopeRoot.isRoot() || scopeRoot.isScript()) {
return castToObject(scopeRoot.getJSType());
} else if (scopeRoot.isModuleBody()) {
return null;
}
checkArgument(scopeRoot.isFunction(), scopeRoot);
JSType nodeType = scopeRoot.getJSType();
if (nodeType != null && nodeType.isFunctionType()) {
return nodeType.toMaybeFunctionType().getTypeOfThis();
} else {
// Executed when the current scope has not been typechecked.
return null;
}
}
/**
* The set of ways in which JSDoc and identifier usage can interact.
*
*
Before ES6, for a given type, there was no way to differentate the declaration of the
* constructor function, namespace object, and type; the declaration of all three constructs was
* the same node. This lead to some assumptions were made about how access-control modifiers
* applied to each.
*
*
At ES6, class-syntax separated the constructor function from the namespace object and type
* declaration. This allowed finer grained control over access-control modifiers; however it broke
* some of the eariler assumptions.
*
*
This type exists to simplify maintaining both sets of assumptions. It allows other code to
* branch on behaviour in a more obvious way.
*
*
TODO(b/113127707): Make this unnecessary by better modeling or decomposing this pass.
*/
private static enum IdentifierBehaviour {
NON_CONSTRUCTOR,
ES5_CLASS_INVOCATION,
ES5_CLASS_NAMESPACE,
ES6_CLASS_INVOCATION,
ES6_CLASS_NAMESPACE;
public static IdentifierBehaviour select(Node target) {
JSType type = target.getJSType();
if (type == null || !type.isFunctionType()) {
// If we aren't sure what we're dealing with be more strict.
return IdentifierBehaviour.NON_CONSTRUCTOR;
}
FunctionType ctorType = type.toMaybeFunctionType();
if (!ctorType.isConstructor()) {
return IdentifierBehaviour.NON_CONSTRUCTOR;
}
boolean isInvocation = NodeUtil.isInvocationTarget(target) || isExtendsTarget(target);
boolean isEs6 = (ctorType.getSource() != null) && ctorType.getSource().isClass();
if (!isEs6) {
return isInvocation
? IdentifierBehaviour.ES5_CLASS_INVOCATION
: IdentifierBehaviour.ES5_CLASS_NAMESPACE;
} else {
return isInvocation
? IdentifierBehaviour.ES6_CLASS_INVOCATION
: IdentifierBehaviour.ES6_CLASS_NAMESPACE;
}
}
}
/**
* A representation of an object property reference in JS code.
*
*
This is an abstraction to smooth over the various AST structures that can act on
* properties. It is not useful for names (variables) or anonymous JS constructs.
*
*
This class should only be used within {@link CheckAccessControls}. Having package-private
* visibility is a quirk of {@link AutoValue}.
*/
@AutoValue
abstract static class PropertyReference {
public static Builder builder() {
return new AutoValue_CheckAccessControls_PropertyReference.Builder();
}
/** The {@link Node} that spawned this reference. */
public abstract Node getSourceNode();
public abstract String getName();
/** The type from which the property is referenced, not necessarily the one that declared it. */
public abstract ObjectType getReceiverType();
public abstract boolean isMutation();
public abstract boolean isDeclaration();
public abstract boolean isOverride();
/**
* A lazy source for a human-readable type name to use when generating messages.
*
*
Most users probably want {@link #getReadableTypeNameOrDefault()}.
*/
public abstract Supplier getReadableTypeName();
@AutoValue.Builder
abstract interface Builder {
Builder setSourceNode(Node node);
Builder setName(String name);
Builder setReceiverType(ObjectType receiverType);
Builder setMutation(boolean isMutation);
Builder setDeclaration(boolean isDeclaration);
Builder setOverride(boolean isOverride);
Builder setReadableTypeName(Supplier typeName);
PropertyReference build();
}
// Derived properties.
public final Node getParentNode() {
return getSourceNode().getParent();
}
public final JSType getJSType() {
return getSourceNode().getJSType();
}
@Nullable
public final JSDocInfo getJSDocInfo() {
return NodeUtil.getBestJSDocInfo(getSourceNode());
}
public final boolean isDocumentedDeclaration() {
return isDeclaration() && (getJSDocInfo() != null);
}
public final boolean isDeletion() {
return getSourceNode().getParent().isDelProp();
}
public final String getReadableTypeNameOrDefault() {
String preferred = getReadableTypeName().get();
return preferred.isEmpty() ? getReceiverType().toString() : preferred;
}
}
@Nullable
private PropertyReference createPropertyReference(Node sourceNode) {
Node parent = sourceNode.getParent();
@Nullable JSDocInfo jsdoc = NodeUtil.getBestJSDocInfo(sourceNode);
PropertyReference.Builder builder = PropertyReference.builder();
switch (sourceNode.getToken()) {
case GETPROP:
{
boolean isLValue = NodeUtil.isLValue(sourceNode);
builder
.setName(sourceNode.getLastChild().getString())
.setReceiverType(boxedOrUnknown(sourceNode.getFirstChild().getJSType()))
// Props are always mutated as L-values, even when assigned `undefined`.
.setMutation(isLValue || sourceNode.getParent().isDelProp())
.setDeclaration(parent.isExprResult())
// TODO(b/113704668): This definition is way too loose. It was used to prevent
// breakages during refactoring and should be tightened.
.setOverride((jsdoc != null) && isLValue)
.setReadableTypeName(
() -> typeRegistry.getReadableTypeName(sourceNode.getFirstChild()));
}
break;
case STRING_KEY:
case GETTER_DEF:
case SETTER_DEF:
case MEMBER_FUNCTION_DEF:
{
switch (parent.getToken()) {
case OBJECTLIT:
// TODO(b/80580110): Eventually object-literal members should be covered by
// `PropertyReference`s. However, doing so initially would have caused too many errors
// in existing code and delayed support for class syntax.
return null;
case OBJECT_PATTERN:
builder
.setName(sourceNode.getString())
.setReceiverType(typeOrUnknown(ObjectType.cast(parent.getJSType())))
.setMutation(false)
.setDeclaration(false)
.setOverride(false)
.setReadableTypeName(() -> typeRegistry.getReadableTypeName(parent));
break;
case CLASS_MEMBERS:
builder
.setName(sourceNode.getString())
.setReceiverType(typeRegistry.getNativeObjectType(JSTypeNative.UNKNOWN_TYPE))
.setMutation(true)
.setDeclaration(true)
// TODO(b/113704668): This definition is way too loose. It was used to prevent
// breakages during refactoring and should be tightened.
.setOverride(jsdoc != null)
.setReadableTypeName(() -> ""); // The default is fine for class types.
JSType ctorType = parent.getParent().getJSType();
if (ctorType != null && ctorType.isFunctionType()) {
FunctionType ctorFunctionType = ctorType.toMaybeFunctionType();
builder.setReceiverType(
sourceNode.isStaticMember()
? ctorFunctionType
: ctorFunctionType.getPrototype());
}
break;
default:
throw new AssertionError();
}
}
break;
default:
return null;
}
return builder.setSourceNode(sourceNode).build();
}
/**
* Returns the effective visibility of the given property. This can differ from the property's
* declared visibility if the property is inherited from a superclass, or if the file's
* {@code @fileoverview} JsDoc specifies a default visibility.
*
* TODO(b/111789692): The following methods are forked from `AccessControlUtils`. Consider
* consolidating them.
*
* @param referenceType The JavaScript type of the property.
* @param fileVisibilityMap A map of {@code @fileoverview} visibility annotations, used to compute
* the property's default visibility.
* @param codingConvention The coding convention in effect (if any), used to determine whether the
* property is private by lexical convention (example: trailing underscore).
*/
static Visibility getEffectivePropertyVisibility(
PropertyReference propRef,
ObjectType referenceType,
ImmutableMap fileVisibilityMap,
@Nullable CodingConvention codingConvention) {
String propertyName = propRef.getName();
boolean isOverride = propRef.isOverride();
StaticSourceFile definingSource =
AccessControlUtils.getDefiningSource(propRef.getSourceNode(), referenceType, propertyName);
Visibility fileOverviewVisibility = fileVisibilityMap.get(definingSource);
ObjectType objectType =
AccessControlUtils.getObjectType(referenceType, isOverride, propertyName);
if (isOverride) {
Visibility overridden =
AccessControlUtils.getOverriddenPropertyVisibility(objectType, propertyName);
return AccessControlUtils.getEffectiveVisibilityForOverriddenProperty(
overridden, fileOverviewVisibility, propertyName, codingConvention);
} else {
return getEffectiveVisibilityForNonOverriddenProperty(
propRef, objectType, fileOverviewVisibility, codingConvention);
}
}
/**
* Returns the effective visibility of the given non-overridden property. Non-overridden
* properties without an explicit visibility annotation receive the default visibility declared in
* the file's {@code @fileoverview} block, if one exists.
*
* TODO(b/111789692): The following methods are forked from `AccessControlUtils`. Consider
* consolidating them.
*/
private static Visibility getEffectiveVisibilityForNonOverriddenProperty(
PropertyReference propRef,
ObjectType objectType,
@Nullable Visibility fileOverviewVisibility,
@Nullable CodingConvention codingConvention) {
String propertyName = propRef.getName();
if (codingConvention != null && codingConvention.isPrivate(propertyName)) {
return Visibility.PRIVATE;
}
Visibility raw = Visibility.INHERITED;
if (objectType != null) {
JSDocInfo jsdoc = objectType.getOwnPropertyJSDocInfo(propertyName);
if (jsdoc != null) {
raw = jsdoc.getVisibility();
}
}
JSType type = propRef.getJSType();
boolean createdFromGoogProvide = (type != null && type.isLiteralObject());
// Ignore @fileoverview visibility when computing the effective visibility
// for properties created by goog.provide.
//
// ProcessClosurePrimitives rewrites goog.provide()s as object literal
// declarations, but the exact form depends on the ordering of the
// input files. If goog.provide('a.b.c') occurs in the inputs before
// goog.provide('a'), it is rewritten like
//
// var a={};a.b={}a.b.c={};
//
// If the file containing goog.provide('a.b.c') also declares
// a @fileoverview visibility, it must not apply to b, as this would make
// every a.b.* namespace effectively package-private.
return (raw != Visibility.INHERITED || fileOverviewVisibility == null || createdFromGoogProvide)
? raw
: fileOverviewVisibility;
}
}