data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/02ace/02ace956f9868cf2a1a780bd2c0a517cd3a46077" alt="JAR search and dependency download from the Maven repository"
data.3news-bydate.train.rec.sport.hockey.54089 Maven / Gradle / Ivy
The newest version!
From: [email protected] (Gerald Olchowy)
Subject: Re: Wings will win
Organization: University of Toronto Chemistry Department
Lines: 47
In article [email protected] (Randy A. Graca) writes:
>
>It's true that Vancouver did not make the playoffs for many a year before
>Quinn came, but in those years the Smythe Division was a lot--I mean *a lot*--
>tougher division than the Norris, also known as the "Snorris", division.
>Vancouver had to play Edmonton and Calgary, both very legitimate Stanley
>Cup contenders, eight times a year, while Detroit got to play such
>powerhouses as Toronto and Minnesota. Now, Edmonton is hardly even a force
>in the league, and the Smythe even has the mighty San Jose sharks, while
Them thar's fighting words...hardly a force...geez...miss the playoffs
once in 15 years, and even after making the final four 3 times in the
last five years, and everyone thinks its doomsville.
>over this same period of time in which Vancouver was improving, so was
>everybody in the Norris (except St. Louis). Detroit had to improve just
>to keep up with the competition in their division. They had to improve *a
>lot* to get better than their competition in the Norris.
>
>Bryan Murray inherited a team with very little talent. For really good
>players, they had Yzerman, Burr, and Probert, and that was about it. (And
>no doubt some will dispute whether Burr and Probert were that good). The
>rest were either very green rookies or washed up veterans. The only reason
>they got as far as they did in the years before Murray came was due to the
>coaching of Demers, who, at least at first, got every last ounce of effort
>possible out of his team. Then, even his coaching began to degrade.
>
Fedorov, Primeau, Kozlov, Lidstrom, Sillinger, Konstantinov, Drake,
Kennedy, Racine, and Cheveldae were already in the pipeline due to
Devellano...Murray inherited these guys...in addition to Yzerman,
Probert, Carson, Chiasson, etc.
>There are a number of reasons why Detroit wasn't in as bad a shape standings
>wise when Murray took over as Vanc. was when Quinn took over, some of which
>I outlined above, but Murray did not have any better personnel to work with
>at the outset than did Quinn, with the exception of Yzerman. And one player
>cannot alone make a team into a Stanley Cup contender, as I'm sure everyone
>reading this will agree.
>
No...Quinn had far less...Murray took over Detroit at a time to
take advantage of all of Devellano's good drafting...if Devellano
had not given in to Demers request to make the Oates trade, he might
still be GM.
Gerald
© 2015 - 2025 Weber Informatics LLC | Privacy Policy