iaik.pkcs.pkcs11.objects.PKCS11Object Maven / Gradle / Ivy
Show all versions of sunpkcs11-wrapper Show documentation
// Copyright (c) 2002 Graz University of Technology. All rights reserved.
//
// Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
// modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions are met:
//
// 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright notice,
// this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
//
// 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright notice,
// this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the documentation
// and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
//
// 3. The end-user documentation included with the redistribution, if any, must
// include the following acknowledgment:
//
// "This product includes software developed by IAIK of Graz University of
// Technology."
//
// Alternately, this acknowledgment may appear in the software itself, if and
// wherever such third-party acknowledgments normally appear.
//
// 4. The names "Graz University of Technology" and "IAIK of Graz University of
// Technology" must not be used to endorse or promote products derived from
// this software without prior written permission.
//
// 5. Products derived from this software may not be called "IAIK PKCS Wrapper",
// nor may "IAIK" appear in their name, without prior written permission of
// Graz University of Technology.
//
// THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS" AND ANY EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED
// WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED
// WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR
// PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE LICENSOR BE
// LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY,
// OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO,
// PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA,
// OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON
// ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY,
// OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY
// OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE
// POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.
package iaik.pkcs.pkcs11.objects;
import iaik.pkcs.pkcs11.*;
import iaik.pkcs.pkcs11.wrapper.PKCS11Constants;
import iaik.pkcs.pkcs11.wrapper.PKCS11Exception;
import sun.security.pkcs11.wrapper.CK_ATTRIBUTE;
import sun.security.pkcs11.wrapper.PKCS11;
import java.util.Enumeration;
import java.util.Hashtable;
import java.util.Vector;
/**
* An object of this class represents an object as defined by PKCS#11.
* An object is of a specific class: DATA, CERTIFICATE, PUBLIC_KEY, PRIVATE_KEY,
* SECRET_KEY, HW_FEATURE, DOMAIN_PARAMETERS or VENDOR_DEFINED.
* If an application needs to use vendor-defined objects, it must set a
* VendorDefinedObjectBuilder using the setVendorDefinedObjectBuilder method.
*
* @author Karl Scheibelhofer
* @version 1.0
*/
// CHECKSTYLE:SKIP
public class PKCS11Object {
/**
* This interface defines the available object classes as defined by
* PKCS#11:
* DATA, CERTIFICATE, PUBLIC_KEY, PRIVATE_KEY, SECRET_KEY, HW_FEATURE,
* DOMAIN_PARAMETERS or VENDOR_DEFINED.
*
* @author Karl Scheibelhofer
* @version 1.0
*/
public interface ObjectClass {
/**
* The identifier for a data object or any sub-class of it.
*/
long DATA = PKCS11Constants.CKO_DATA;
/**
* The identifier for a certificate object or any sub-class of it.
*/
long CERTIFICATE = PKCS11Constants.CKO_CERTIFICATE;
/**
* The identifier for a public key object or any sub-class of it.
*/
long PUBLIC_KEY = PKCS11Constants.CKO_PUBLIC_KEY;
/**
* The identifier for a private key object or any sub-class of it.
*/
long PRIVATE_KEY = PKCS11Constants.CKO_PRIVATE_KEY;
/**
* The identifier for a secret key object or any sub-class of it.
*/
long SECRET_KEY = PKCS11Constants.CKO_SECRET_KEY;
/**
* The identifier for a hardware feature object or any sub-class of it.
*/
long HW_FEATURE = PKCS11Constants.CKO_HW_FEATURE;
/**
* The identifier for a domain parameters object or any sub-class of it.
*/
long DOMAIN_PARAMETERS = PKCS11Constants.CKO_DOMAIN_PARAMETERS;
/**
* The identifier for a mechanism object or any sub-class of it.
*/
long MECHANISM = PKCS11Constants.CKO_MECHANISM;
/**
* The identifier for a vendor-defined object. Any Long object with a
* value bigger than this one is also a valid vendor-defined object
* class identifier.
*/
long VENDOR_DEFINED = PKCS11Constants.CKO_VENDOR_DEFINED;
}
/**
* If an application uses vendor defined objects, it must implement this
* interface and install such an object handler using
* setVendorDefinedObjectBuilder.
*
* @author Karl Scheibelhofer
* @version 1.0
*/
public interface VendorDefinedObjectBuilder {
/**
* This method should instantiate an PKCS11Object of this class or of
* any sub-class. It can use the given handles and PKCS#11 module to
* retrieve attributes of the PKCS#11 object from the token.
*
* @param session
* The session to use for reading attributes. This session must
* have the appropriate rights; i.e. it must be a user-session,
* if it is a private object.
* @param objectHandle
* The object handle as given from the PKCS#111 module.
* @return The object representing the PKCS#11 object.
* The returned object can be casted to the
* according sub-class.
* @exception PKCS11Exception
* If getting the attributes failed.
*/
PKCS11Object build(Session session, long objectHandle)
throws PKCS11Exception;
}
/**
* The currently set vendor defined object builder, or null.
*/
protected static VendorDefinedObjectBuilder vendorObjectBuilder;
/**
* A table holding string representations for all known key types. Table key
* is the key type as Long object.
*/
protected static Hashtable objectClassNames;
/**
* Contains all attribute objects an object possesses. No matter if an
* attribute is set present or not, it is part of this collection.
* The key of this table is the attribute type as Long.
*/
protected Hashtable attributeTable;
/**
* The class type of this object. One of ObjectClass, or one that has a
* bigger value than VENDOR_DEFINED.
*/
protected ObjectClassAttribute objectClass;
/**
* The object handle as given from the PKCS#11 driver.
*/
protected long objectHandle = -1;
/**
* The default constructor. An application use this constructor to
* instantiate an object that serves as a template. It may also be useful
* for working with vendor-defined objects.
*/
public PKCS11Object() {
attributeTable = new Hashtable<>(32);
allocateAttributes();
}
/**
* The subclasses that are used to create objects by reading the attributes
* from the token should call this super-constructor first.
* The getInstance method also uses this constructor, if it can not
* determine the class type of the object or if the type class is a vendor
* defined one.
*
* @param session
* The session to use for reading attributes. This session must
* have the appropriate rights; i.e. it must be a user-session, if
* it is a private object.
* @param objectHandle
* The object handle as given from the PKCS#111 module.
* @exception TokenException
* If getting the attributes failed.
*/
protected PKCS11Object(Session session, long objectHandle)
throws TokenException {
this.attributeTable = new Hashtable<>(32);
allocateAttributes();
this.objectHandle = objectHandle;
readAttributes(session);
}
/**
* The object creation mechanism of ObjectAccess uses this method to create
* an instance of an PKCS#11 object. This method reads the object class
* attribute and calls the getInstance method of the according sub-class. If
* the object class is a vendor defined it uses the
* VendorDefinedObjectBuilder set by the application. If no object could be
* constructed, Returns null.
*
* @param session
* The session to use for reading attributes. This session must
* have the appropriate rights; i.e. it must be a user-session, if
* it is a private object.
* @param objectHandle
* The object handle as given from the PKCS#111 module.
* @return The object representing the PKCS#11 object.
* The returned object can be casted to the
* according sub-class.
* @exception TokenException
* If getting the attributes failed.
*/
public static PKCS11Object getInstance(Session session, long objectHandle)
throws TokenException {
Util.requireNonNull("session", session);
ObjectClassAttribute objectClassAttribute = new ObjectClassAttribute();
getAttributeValue(session, objectHandle, objectClassAttribute);
Long objectClass = objectClassAttribute.getLongValue();
PKCS11Object newObject;
if (objectClassAttribute.isPresent() && (objectClass != null)) {
if (objectClass.equals(ObjectClass.PRIVATE_KEY)) {
newObject = PrivateKey.getInstance(session, objectHandle);
} else if (objectClass.equals(ObjectClass.PUBLIC_KEY)) {
newObject = PublicKey.getInstance(session, objectHandle);
} else if (objectClass.equals(ObjectClass.CERTIFICATE)) {
newObject = Certificate.getInstance(session, objectHandle);
} else if (objectClass.equals(ObjectClass.SECRET_KEY)) {
newObject = SecretKey.getInstance(session, objectHandle);
} else if (objectClass.equals(ObjectClass.DATA)) {
newObject = Data.getInstance(session, objectHandle);
} else if (objectClass.equals(ObjectClass.DOMAIN_PARAMETERS)) {
newObject = DomainParameters.getInstance(session, objectHandle);
} else if (objectClass.equals(ObjectClass.MECHANISM)) {
newObject = Mechanism.getInstance(session, objectHandle);
} else if (objectClass.equals(ObjectClass.HW_FEATURE)) {
newObject = HardwareFeature.getInstance(session, objectHandle);
} else if ((objectClass & ObjectClass.VENDOR_DEFINED) != 0L) {
newObject = getUnknownObject(session, objectHandle);
} else {
newObject = getUnknownObject(session, objectHandle);
}
} else {
newObject = getUnknownObject(session, objectHandle);
}
return newObject;
}
/**
* Try to create an object which has no or an unknown object class
* attribute. This implementation will try to use a vendor defined object
* builder, if such has been set. If this is impossible or fails, it will
* create just a simple
* {@link iaik.pkcs.pkcs11.objects.PKCS11Object PKCS11Object }.
*
* @param session
* The session to use.
* @param objectHandle
* The handle of the object
* @return A new PKCS11Object.
* @throws TokenException
* If no object could be created.
*/
protected static PKCS11Object getUnknownObject(Session session,
long objectHandle) throws TokenException {
Util.requireNonNull("session", session);
PKCS11Object newObject;
if (vendorObjectBuilder != null) {
try {
newObject = vendorObjectBuilder.build(session, objectHandle);
} catch (PKCS11Exception ex) {
// we can just treat it like some unknown type of object
newObject = new PKCS11Object(session, objectHandle);
}
} else {
// we can just treat it like some unknown type of object
newObject = new PKCS11Object(session, objectHandle);
}
return newObject;
}
/**
* Set a vendor-defined object builder that should be called to create an
* instance of an vendor-defined PKCS#11 object; i.e. an instance of a
* vendor defined sub-class of this class.
*
* @param builder
* The vendor-defined object builder. Null to clear any previously
* installed vendor-defined builder.
*/
public static void setVendorDefinedObjectBuilder(
VendorDefinedObjectBuilder builder) {
vendorObjectBuilder = builder;
}
/**
* Get the given object class as string.
*
* @param objectClass
* The object class to get as string.
* @return A string denoting the object class; e.g. "Private Key".
*/
public static String getObjectClassName(Long objectClass) {
Util.requireNonNull("objectClass", objectClass);
String objectClassName;
if ((objectClass & PKCS11Constants.CKO_VENDOR_DEFINED) != 0L) {
objectClassName = "Vendor Defined";
} else {
if (objectClassNames == null) {
// setup object class names table
objectClassNames = new Hashtable<>(7);
objectClassNames.put(ObjectClass.DATA, "Data");
objectClassNames.put(ObjectClass.CERTIFICATE, "Certificate");
objectClassNames.put(ObjectClass.PUBLIC_KEY, "Public Key");
objectClassNames.put(ObjectClass.PRIVATE_KEY, "Private Key");
objectClassNames.put(ObjectClass.SECRET_KEY, "Secret Key");
objectClassNames.put(ObjectClass.HW_FEATURE,
"Hardware Feature");
objectClassNames.put(ObjectClass.DOMAIN_PARAMETERS,
"Domain Parameters");
}
objectClassName = objectClassNames.get(objectClass);
if (objectClassName == null) {
objectClassName = "";
}
}
return objectClassName;
}
/**
* Get the currently set vendor-defined object builder.
*
* @return The currently set vendor-defined object builder or null if none
* is set.
*/
public static VendorDefinedObjectBuilder getVendorDefinedObjectBuilder() {
return vendorObjectBuilder;
}
/**
* Put all attributes of the given object into the attributes table of this
* object. This method is only static to be able to access invoke the
* implementation of this method for each class separately.
*
* @param object
* The object to handle.
*/
protected static void putAttributesInTable(PKCS11Object object) {
Util.requireNonNull("object", object);
object.attributeTable.put(Attribute.CLASS, object.objectClass);
}
/**
* Allocates the attribute objects for this class and adds them to the
* attribute table.
*/
protected void allocateAttributes() {
objectClass = new ObjectClassAttribute();
putAttributesInTable(this);
}
/**
* Compares all member variables of this object with the other object.
* Returns only true, if all are equal in both objects.
*
* @param otherObject
* The other object to compare to.
* @return True, if other is an instance of this class and all member
* variables of both objects are equal. False, otherwise.
*/
@Override
public boolean equals(Object otherObject) {
if (this == otherObject) {
return true;
} else if (!(otherObject instanceof PKCS11Object)) {
return false;
}
PKCS11Object other = (PKCS11Object) otherObject;
return (this.objectHandle == other.objectHandle)
&& this.objectClass.equals(other.objectClass);
}
/**
* Return the table that contains all attributes of this object.
* The key to this table is the attribute type as Long object.
*
* @return The table of all attributes of this object. Key is the attribute
* type as Long. This table is unmodifiable.
*/
@SuppressWarnings("unchecked")
public Hashtable getAttributeTable() {
return (Hashtable) attributeTable.clone();
}
/**
* Allows for putting attributes into the table without knowing the
* {@link Attribute} at compile-time.
*
* @param attribute
* the attribute identifier as a {@link long} value
* @param value
* the value
* @throws UnsupportedAttributeException
* the specified attribute identifier is not available for this
* {@link PKCS11Object} instance.
* @throws ClassCastException
* the given value type is not valid for this {@link Attribute}
* instance.
*/
public void putAttribute(long attribute, Object value)
throws UnsupportedAttributeException {
Attribute myAttribute = getAttribute(attribute);
if (null == myAttribute) {
throw new UnsupportedAttributeException(
"Unsupported attribute 0x" + Long.toHexString(attribute)
+ " for " + this.getClass().getName());
}
myAttribute.setValue(value);
}
/**
* Gets the attribute.
*
* @param attribute
* the attribute identifier as a {@link long} value
* @return the attribute
*/
public Attribute getAttribute(long attribute) {
return attributeTable.get(attribute);
}
/**
* Removes the attribute.
*
* @param attribute
* the attribute identifier as a {@link long} value
*/
public void removeAttribute(long attribute) {
getAttribute(attribute).setPresent(false);
}
/**
* Gets the object handle of the underlying PKCS#11 object on the token.
*
* @return The object handle of the corresponding PKCS#11 object.
*/
public long getObjectHandle() {
return objectHandle;
}
/**
* Sets the object handle of the underlying PKCS#11 object on the token.
* An application will rarely need to call this method itself during normal
* operation.
*
* @param objectHandle
* The object handle of the corresponding PKCS#11 object.
*/
public void setObjectHandle(long objectHandle) {
this.objectHandle = objectHandle;
}
/**
* Gets the object class attribute of the PKCS#11 object. Its value must be
* one of those defined in the ObjectClass interface or one with an value
* bigger than ObjectClass.VENDOR_DEFINED.
*
* @return The object class attribute.
*/
public LongAttribute getObjectClass() {
return objectClass;
}
/**
* Returns the PKCS#11 attributes of this object. The collection
* contains CK_ATTRIBUTE objects, one for each present attribute of this
* object; e.g. for each attribute that has a set value (which might be
* sensitive).
*
* The array representation of this collection can be used directly as
* input for the PKCS#11 wrapper. The Session class uses this method for
* various object operations.
*
* @return An collection of CK_ATTRIBUTE objects.
*/
public Vector getSetAttributes() {
Vector attributeCollection =
new Vector<>(attributeTable.size());
Enumeration attributeEnumeration =
attributeTable.elements();
while (attributeEnumeration.hasMoreElements()) {
Attribute attribute = attributeEnumeration.nextElement();
if (attribute.isPresent()) {
CK_ATTRIBUTE ckAttribute = attribute.getCkAttribute();
attributeCollection.addElement(ckAttribute);
}
}
return attributeCollection;
}
/**
* Returns the PKCS#11 attributes of an object. The array
* contains CK_ATTRIBUTE objects, one for each set attribute of this object;
* e.g. for each attribute that is not null.
* The array can be used directly as input for the PKCS#11 wrapper. The
* Session class uses this method for various object operations.
*
* @param object
* The iaik.pkcs.pkcs11.object.Object object to get the attributes
* from.
* @param vendorCodeConverter
* The vendor code converter.
* @return An array of CK_ATTRIBUTE objects. null, if the given object is
* null.
* @exception PKCS11Exception
* If setting the attribute values.
*/
public static CK_ATTRIBUTE[] getSetAttributes(
PKCS11Object object,
VendorCodeConverter vendorCodeConverter)
throws PKCS11Exception {
Vector setAttributes = (object != null)
? object.getSetAttributes() : null;
if (setAttributes == null) {
return null;
}
// replace the generic key type to vendor specific one.
if (object instanceof Key && vendorCodeConverter != null) {
Long keyType = ((Key) object).getKeyType().getLongValue();
if (keyType != null && (keyType & PKCS11Constants.CKK_VENDOR_DEFINED) != 0) {
long vendorKeyType = vendorCodeConverter.genericToVendorCKK(keyType);
if (vendorKeyType != keyType) {
Vector newSetAttributes = new Vector<>();
for (CK_ATTRIBUTE attr : setAttributes) {
if (attr.type == PKCS11Constants.CKA_KEY_TYPE) {
attr = new CK_ATTRIBUTE(attr.type, vendorKeyType); // replace the keyType
}
newSetAttributes.add(attr);
}
setAttributes = newSetAttributes;
}
}
}
return Util.convertAttributesVectorToArray(setAttributes);
}
/**
* The overriding of this method should ensure that the objects of this
* class work correctly in a hashtable.
*
* @return The hash code of this object.
*/
@Override
public int hashCode() {
return objectClass.hashCode() ^ ((int) objectHandle);
}
/**
* Read the values of the attributes of this object from the token.
*
* @param session
* The session to use for reading attributes. This session must
* have the appropriate rights; i.e. it must be a user-session, if
* it is a private object.
* @exception TokenException
* If getting the attributes failed.
*/
public void readAttributes(Session session)
throws TokenException {
Util.requireNonNull("session", session);
// no attributes that we need to read, subclasses set the CLASS
// attribute
}
/**
* Returns a string representation of the current object. The
* output is only for debugging purposes and should not be used for other
* purposes.
*
* @return A string presentation of this object for debugging output.
*/
@Override
public String toString() {
StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder(32);
sb.append(" PKCS11Object Class: ");
if (objectClass != null) {
sb.append(objectClass.toString());
} else {
sb.append("");
}
return sb.toString();
}
/**
* Returns a string representation of the current object. Some
* parameters can be set to manipulate the output. The output is only for
* debugging purposes and should not be used for other purposes.
*
* @param newline
* true if the output should start in a new line
* @param withName
* true if the type of the attribute should be returned too
* @param indent
* the indent to be used
* @return A string presentation of this object for debugging output.
*/
public String toString(boolean newline, boolean withName, String indent) {
StringBuilder sb = new StringBuilder(1024);
Enumeration attributesEnumeration = attributeTable.elements();
boolean firstAttribute = !newline;
while (attributesEnumeration.hasMoreElements()) {
Attribute attribute = attributesEnumeration.nextElement();
if (attribute.isPresent()) {
if (!firstAttribute) {
sb.append("\n");
}
sb.append(indent);
sb.append(attribute.toString(withName));
firstAttribute = false;
}
}
return sb.toString();
}
/**
* This method reads the attribute specified by attribute from
* the token using the given session.
* The object from which to read the attribute is specified using the
* objectHandle. The attribute will contain
* the results.
* If the attempt to read the attribute returns
* CKR_ATTRIBUTE_TYPE_INVALID, this will be indicated by
* setting {@link Attribute#setPresent(boolean)} to false.
* It CKR_ATTRIBUTE_SENSITIVE is returned, the attribute object is
* marked as present
* (by calling {@link Attribute#setPresent(boolean)} with
* true), and in addition as sensitive by calling
* {@link Attribute#setSensitive(boolean)} with true.
*
* @param session
* The session to use for reading the attribute.
* @param objectHandle
* The handle of the object which contains the attribute.
* @param attribute
* The object specifying the attribute type
* (see {@link Attribute#getType()}) and receiving the attribute
* value (see {@link Attribute#setCkAttribute(CK_ATTRIBUTE)}).
* @exception PKCS11Exception
* If getting the attribute failed.
*/
protected static void getAttributeValue(Session session, long objectHandle,
Attribute attribute) throws PKCS11Exception {
Util.requireNonNull("session", session);
PKCS11 pkcs11Module = session.getModule().getPKCS11Module();
long sessionHandle = session.getSessionHandle();
long attributeCode = attribute.getCkAttribute().type;
try {
CK_ATTRIBUTE[] attributeTemplateList = new CK_ATTRIBUTE[1];
attributeTemplateList[0] = new CK_ATTRIBUTE();
attributeTemplateList[0].type = attributeCode;
pkcs11Module.C_GetAttributeValue(sessionHandle, objectHandle,
attributeTemplateList);
attribute.setCkAttribute(attributeTemplateList[0]);
attribute.setPresent(true);
attribute.setSensitive(false);
} catch (sun.security.pkcs11.wrapper.PKCS11Exception ex) {
if (ex.getErrorCode()
== PKCS11Constants.CKR_ATTRIBUTE_TYPE_INVALID) {
// this means, that some requested attributes are missing, but
// we can ignore this and proceed; e.g. a v2.01 module won't
// have the object ID attribute
attribute.setPresent(false);
} else if (ex.getErrorCode()
== PKCS11Constants.CKR_ATTRIBUTE_SENSITIVE) {
// this means, that some requested attributes are missing, but
// we can ignore this and proceed; e.g. a v2.01 module won't
// have the object ID attribute
attribute.setPresent(true);
attribute.setSensitive(true);
} else {
// there was a different error that we should propagate
throw new PKCS11Exception(ex);
}
}
}
/**
* This method reads the attributes in a similar way as
* {@link #getAttributeValue}, but a complete array at once. This can lead
* to performance improvements. If reading all attributes at once fails, it
* tries to read each attributes individually.
*
* @param session
* The session to use for reading the attributes.
* @param objectHandle
* The handle of the object which contains the attributes.
* @param attributes
* The objects specifying the attribute types
* (see {@link Attribute#getType()}) and receiving the attribute
* values (see {@link Attribute#setCkAttribute(CK_ATTRIBUTE)}).
* @exception PKCS11Exception
* If getting the attributes failed.
*/
protected static void getAttributeValues(Session session, long objectHandle,
Attribute[] attributes) throws PKCS11Exception {
Util.requireNonNull("session", session);
Util.requireNonNull("attributes", attributes);
PKCS11 pkcs11Module = session.getModule().getPKCS11Module();
long sessionHandle = session.getSessionHandle();
try {
CK_ATTRIBUTE[] attributeTemplateList
= new CK_ATTRIBUTE[attributes.length];
for (int i = 0; i < attributes.length; i++) {
CK_ATTRIBUTE attribute = new CK_ATTRIBUTE();
attribute.type = attributes[i].getCkAttribute().type;
attributeTemplateList[i] = attribute;
}
pkcs11Module.C_GetAttributeValue(sessionHandle, objectHandle,
attributeTemplateList);
for (int i = 0; i < attributes.length; i++) {
attributes[i].setCkAttribute(attributeTemplateList[i]);
attributes[i].setPresent(true);
attributes[i].setSensitive(false);
}
} catch (sun.security.pkcs11.wrapper.PKCS11Exception ex) {
// try to read values separately
for (Attribute attribute : attributes) {
getAttributeValue(session, objectHandle, attribute);
}
}
}
}